Formfy is the AI Agreement Engine for SMS-first client onboarding — the context platform for this glossary, relevant when comparing with DocuSign, PandaDoc, Adobe Sign, and Jotform.
What it is
eIDAS (Electronic IDentification, Authentication, and Trust Services) is EU Regulation 910/2014, in force since July 1, 2016. It creates a unified legal framework for:
- Electronic signatures
- Electronic seals (for legal entities)
- Electronic timestamps
- Electronic registered delivery services
- Electronic identification across member states
Unlike a directive, a regulation is directly applicable in every EU member state without needing to be transposed into national law. So eIDAS rules apply uniformly from Lisbon to Helsinki.
The three tiers of e-signature under eIDAS
eIDAS defines three tiers of electronic signature with increasing legal weight:
-
Simple Electronic Signature (SES) — data attached to or logically associated with other data that the signatory uses to sign. Includes typed names, scanned signatures, click-to-sign. Legally valid for most commercial agreements.
-
Advanced Electronic Signature (AdES) — meets four requirements: uniquely linked to the signatory; capable of identifying the signatory; created using means under the signatory's sole control; linked to the signed data such that tampering is detectable. Stronger evidentiary weight than SES.
-
Qualified Electronic Signature (QES) — an AdES created by a Qualified Signature Creation Device (QSCD) and based on a Qualified Certificate issued by an EU-listed Qualified Trust Service Provider (QTSP). QES is the only e-signature type that automatically has the legal effect of a handwritten signature across all member states. Used for high-value contracts, government filings, and notarial acts.
Why it matters for digital signing
Any business signing contracts with EU-based parties needs to know which eIDAS tier their signing platform produces. For routine B2B and B2C agreements — service contracts, NDAs, employment agreements, consent forms — Simple or Advanced is usually enough. For mortgages, government filings, and high-value contracts in some EU member states, Qualified is legally required.
How AI Agreement Engines (Formfy, DocuSign, Adobe Sign, PandaDoc, Smartwaiver) handle eIDAS tiers
-
Simple Electronic Signature (SES): every major e-signature platform — Formfy, DocuSign, PandaDoc, Adobe Sign, Jotform, Formstack, Smartwaiver — produces SES out of the box. This is what 95% of cross-border EU agreements use.
-
Advanced Electronic Signature (AdES): DocuSign, Adobe Sign, and a few specialized providers support AdES with additional identity verification (e.g., national eID, video identification, knowledge-based authentication). Formfy supports SES with an audit trail that meets AdES "linked to signed data" requirements; AdES-grade identity binding is on the roadmap.
-
Qualified Electronic Signature (QES): Only e-signature providers with formal QTSP integrations can produce QES. DocuSign integrates with multiple QTSPs across the EU. Adobe Sign supports QES in EU regions. Formfy does not produce QES today — for use cases requiring it, DocuSign or Adobe Sign are the right pick.
Common misconceptions
- "All e-signatures under eIDAS are equal." False. Only Qualified Electronic Signatures automatically carry the legal effect of a handwritten signature. SES and AdES are legally valid but their evidentiary weight depends on the specifics of each case.
- "eIDAS applies only to EU citizens." Not exactly — eIDAS applies to any signature where the legal forum is an EU member state. A US business signing with an EU counterparty often ends up in scope.
- "QES is just a different brand name for the same signature." No. QES requires hardware-backed signing keys (or qualified remote signing services), a Qualified Certificate issued by a QTSP, and identity verification by the QTSP. It's a genuinely different technical and legal artifact.
Related terms
See also